Pay equity ruling: Court finds discrimination, but law remains in force
November 21, 2026

Summarised by Centrist
The High Court has ruled that the government's controversial pay equity reforms unjustifiably discriminated against women, but the legislation remains in force, with 33 cancelled pay equity claims still extinguished.
The court also rejected arguments that rushing the law through Parliament without consultation was unlawful.
Justice Paul Radich found that the government's 2025 amendments to the Equal Pay Act breached protections against sex discrimination under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act.
The changes, passed under urgency without select committee scrutiny, cancelled 33 existing claims and imposed tougher requirements on future applicants.
The government argued the reforms were necessary to make the system more sustainable. However, Radich found little evidence that the previous framework was failing.
“The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal,” he said.
The changes were projected to free up approximately $12.8 billion in government Budget allowances over four years.
The court found less discriminatory alternatives could have achieved the government's objectives.
However, Radich ruled that the government was not legally required to consult before introducing legislation and that cancelling existing claims did not breach natural justice protections.
Importantly, the declaration does not overturn the legislation or automatically restore cancelled claims.
Parliament must consider the declaration once it becomes final, but MPs are not legally compelled to repeal the law.
Public Service Association national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons welcomed the decision and urged political parties to restore the previous system.
“No coalition deal should leave this egregious law on the books,” she said.
Aged care worker Lisa Marriner also welcomed the ruling, declaring: “Today we've been heard.”
Outgoing Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden said officials were considering whether to appeal.
“We didn’t think the previous legislative regime got the settings right,” she said.
Editor's note: The court's finding of discrimination rests on how disadvantage is measured. It concluded that women in female-dominated occupations were unfairly disadvantaged by restrictions on access to pay equity claims.
But the pay equity system itself is not symmetrical. Under both the previous Labour government's rules and the amended legislation, male-dominated occupational groups cannot bring equivalent collective claims arguing their work is undervalued compared with female-dominated occupations.
Men can benefit from claims involving predominantly female workforces and pursue individual discrimination complaints, but there is no equivalent collective mechanism for male-dominated jobs.
The Bill of Rights permits special measures to remedy established discrimination. Nevertheless, should a system intended to eliminate sex discrimination provide equivalent remedies for both sexes?
The court has ruled that these particular restrictions were unjustified. Whether the underlying pay equity system is the fairest approach, and how it should be funded, remains a question for Parliament.
Community Discussion
Comment Policy