Voters figured out how to hold politicians accountable. Now the political elite want to ‘fix’ MMP
November 16, 2026

Summarised by Centrist
Former National minister Christopher Finlayson has described MMP as "stuffed", blaming wealthy campaigners for exploiting the system.
Labour's Kieran McAnulty also wants reform, warning that strategic voting could become a permanent feature of elections.
Academics including Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Jonathan Boston are preparing an open letter seeking a parliamentary inquiry into MMP.
The preliminary election results give National 42 electorate seats despite a party vote worth approximately 35 seats, creating a seven-seat overhang. Te Pāti Māori won five electorates on just 0.57% of the party vote, adding another four seats. Parliament would consequently expand to 131 MPs.
ACT leader David Seymour argues that voters are entitled to use their two votes however they choose. Former National MP Nick Smith similarly defended the electorate vote as an important expression of grassroots democracy.
Proposed reforms include limiting overhang seats, expanding Parliament or changing how electorate winners are accommodated. Each would involve trade-offs between proportionality, local representation and parliamentary size.
The official election result is due on November 27.
Editor's note: MMP may have an unintended populist virtue. It allows voters to challenge party leadership without necessarily abandoning their preferred side of politics.
National supporters could retain their local MPs while shifting party votes to ACT or NZ First, potentially strengthening those parties' negotiating power and denying National's leadership valuable list seats. Te Pāti Māori promoted a similar strategy to benefit the left.
In an April 2025 Guardian article, Finlayson, a major proponent of co-governance, warned that ACT gaining influence at National's expense would be bad for New Zealand, particularly because of its Treaty policies.
He condemned the right's split-vote campaign, yet we found no equivalent public objection from him when Te Pāti Māori promoted its strategy in August.
As Centrist previously argued, split voting allows disillusioned voters to punish party leaders without handing power to the opposition, turning MMP into a powerful tool of voter accountability.
Community Discussion
Comment Policy