CENTRIST
.
News you need
Sign in to Centrist
Free Account

‘Retreat’ poses the possibility of displacement without compensation, sold as public safety

November 18, 2026

‘Retreat’ poses the possibility of displacement without compensation, sold as public safety

Summarised by Centrist

Residents of three East Cape communities face the prospect of being told their homes are too dangerous to occupy, without any guarantee of compensation or assistance to relocate. 

A Gisborne District Council-commissioned report has identified managed retreat as a long-term option for flood-prone areas, but the council has confirmed it will not fund property buyouts.

The independent review examined Wharekahika (Hicks Bay), Onepoto Bay and Punaruku, including Te Araroa, following devastating flooding in January.

The report ruled out structural protection measures as ineffective or infeasible, identifying managed retreat as an option for properties facing serious risks, including threats to life.

But residents say they have been left in limbo, with little consultation, no clear timetable and no explanation of what retreat would actually involve.

"We've asked what does a managed retreat look like, and they weren't able to answer at this stage," said Te Araroa business owner Nina McClutchie.

"I think it's shocking. You really can't come to us and say that without being really transparent right across the board with how this is going to work."

Community advocate Sean Deery accused the council of excluding residents from decisions affecting their futures.

"They should all be there at the table at the beginning of the process, so everyone understands what is going to happen, how it is going to happen."

Council principal scientist Murray Cave disputed claims of inadequate consultation, saying officials "bent over backwards" to speak with affected parties.

However, Cave confirmed the council would not be offering buyout payments. Any funding would have to come from central government.

"If it was being made available to us from the Crown, we'd clearly consider that as an option," he said.

Read more at RNZ 

Receive our free newsletter here

Community Discussion

Comment Policy

Latest News

Loading latest articles