Plunket calls for Ombudsman’s sacking as public-sector accountability comes under scrutiny

Summarised by Centrist

Sean Plunket has called for Chief Ombudsman John Allen to be removed after a speech critics say crossed from independent oversight into political advocacy. It is the latest argument over whether accountability in New Zealand’s public institutions still carries any personal consequences.

Allen is an Officer of Parliament responsible for investigating government agencies, handling Official Information Act complaints and acting independently of political interests.

Speaking at Tūrangawaewae Marae, Allen said he was “standing with and for Kīngitanga”, “fairness” and “systemic change”. He also challenged or invited politicians to share the Māori Queen’s kaupapa.

Plunket described the speech as “activist speech-making” that compromised the appearance of impartiality. He said Allen should apologise publicly and then leave office.

Plunket reported that Speaker Gerry Brownlee was displeased and expected to meet Allen, citing unnamed sources. That has not been publicly confirmed. ACT MP Todd Stephenson has raised the speech with the Speaker.

Allen did not endorse a party or criticise the Government in the excerpt. Supporting unity, fairness and Māori economic advancement is not necessarily partisan. The issue is whether an Ombudsman charged with judging government agencies should publicly align himself with a movement’s programme and call for “systemic change”.The controversy follows several cases in which senior officials have accepted responsibility without losing their positions.

MBIE chief executive Nic Blakeley remained in office after Parliament found his ministry deliberately misled MPs over a failed $33 million technology project. Blakeley said “accountability rests with me” and offered to resign, but Public Service Commissioner Sir Brian Roche declined the offer.

MSD chief executive Debbie Power also remains after a review found more than 30,000 payments were wrongly suspended, leaving thousands of people short and producing $2.5 million in arrears. Concerns circulated for three months before reaching senior leadership. Power said, “I’m certainly accountable”, but added, “My job is to fix this.”

At Tauranga City Council, an independent review found systemic failures preceding the preventable Mount Maunganui campground landslide that killed six people. It identified more than two decades of warnings but attributed blame to no individual. Other investigations remain underway.

Increasingly, accountability appears to mean accepting responsibility, apologising and promising improvement while remaining in office. Plunket’s challenge is whether the country should expect something more.

Hear more at YouTube | NewstalkZB | RNZ

Image: Ti.mo

Receive our free newsletter here