CENTRIST
.
News you need
Sign in to Centrist
Free Account

Major Florida study finds higher mortality among Pfizer vaccine recipients than Moderna recipients

November 16, 2026

Major Florida study finds higher mortality among Pfizer vaccine recipients than Moderna recipients

Summarised by Centrist

A new peer-reviewed study involving nearly two million Florida adults has found significantly higher death rates among people who received Pfizer's COVID vaccine compared with Moderna's. 

The findings raise questions about differences between the two vaccines, although researchers have not established that either caused the deaths.

The study, published in Global Epidemiology, examined vaccination and mortality records for 1,962,822 Florida adults who received their first Pfizer or Moderna dose between December 2020 and August 2021.

Researchers matched recipients according to age, sex, ethnicity, vaccination timing and other demographic factors, then tracked deaths over 12 months.

Compared with Moderna recipients, those given Pfizer had a 40% higher relative risk of death from any cause, a 57% higher risk of cardiovascular death, a 91% higher risk of COVID death and a 37% higher risk of death from non-COVID causes.

Overall mortality was approximately 784 deaths per 100,000 Pfizer recipients, compared with 562 per 100,000 Moderna recipients. Differences in cardiovascular and COVID mortality were largely driven by adults aged 60 and over.

Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, a study co-author, told Children's Health Defense that the findings highlighted problems with vaccine monitoring, arguing that "our system for evaluating vaccine safety is broken".

Another co-author, MIT professor Retsef Levi, acknowledged the study was "not designed to prove causality", but said the findings suggested the vaccines could have different effects beyond preventing COVID.

The researchers identified several possible explanations, including Moderna offering stronger protection against COVID and differences in recipients' underlying health.

Independent biostatisticians have also cautioned that the groups were not fully matched for existing medical conditions. The study included no unvaccinated comparison group, meaning it cannot establish whether either vaccine increased overall mortality.

Read more at Children’s Health Defense

Receive our free newsletter here

Community Discussion

Comment Policy

Latest News

Loading latest articles